The Best Places in Lexington for a Sweet Treat

Looking to satisfy your sweet tooth? Lexington, MA has something sweet for nearly any taste and craving, from locally made ice cream, to pastries served during afternoon tea, fan-favorite donuts, and so much more!

Save this post for your next visit, and plan to stop for something sweet while exploring local museums, historic sites, and art around town. 

Vintage Tea and Cake Company 

For those looking for an elegant and cozy atmosphere, Lexington’s Vintage Tea and Cake Company offers afternoon tea. Enjoy a large selection of teas, pastries, scones, finger sandwiches, and sparkling wine (for those 21+). With a location right in Lexington Center, the Vintage Tea and Cake Company is bright, fun, and a great place to spend time with family and friends while feasting on delicious desserts.

Afternoon tea can be quite the popular outing, so we recommend making reservations ahead of your visit (especially if you plan to dine in on a weekend). View menus and book a table at vintageteaandcake.com.

Liberty Sweets

Liberty Sweets is Lexington’s premier candy shop, only steps away from the famous Lexington Battle Green. The store offers a wide selection of candies, from locally made fine chocolates and fudge to bulk candy. At Liberty Sweets, you’ll get a taste of sweet candies while you’re getting a slice of American history. 

This shop is also a must-visit for the holiday season, with nostalgic and homemade chocolates making the perfect gift or stocking stuffer. Their chocolate lineup for Valentine’s Day is also not to be missed while shopping in Lexington Center.

Rancatore’s Ice Cream & Yogurt

You can’t go wrong with a cold sweet treat from Rancatore’s Ice Cream and Yogurt! Here, you can pick from their list of unique flavors like almond joy, sweet cream, lemon lemon snap, and mango sorbet, or go for the classics like vanilla or chocolate.

Order your ice cream in a cup or a yummy sugar cone, or pick up an ice cream cake for a special occasion. You can even find dog-friendly ice cream for furry friends at home! And if you’re feeling a little more indulgent, make your own sundae and top it with homemade hot fudge sauce.

Royal Pastry Shop

You’ll find pastries galore at Royal Pastry in Lexington. With roots dating back to 1941, here you can choose from pastries, cakes, pies, and cookies, all made from old family recipes. Try the famous cannoli cake, the chocolate nut brownie, or pizzelles. 

Looking for breakfast on your way into town? Royal Pastry is also a great stop for something sweet before setting off for a full day in Lexington.

Nouve

This upscale French artisanal bakery combines age-old French methodologies with Asian ingredients. You can choose from delicious croissants, fruit danishes, apple turnovers, and honey toast.

Grab them early in the morning for a sweet start to your day or have them for a little afternoon snack. Nouve’s pastry selection is baked fresh onsite daily, and they are always coming up with new and tasty creations. 

Sweet Thyme Bakery

Sweet Thyme Bakery is a charming local favorite known for its beautifully made cakes and pastries. Their display case is always tempting, whether you’re stopping in for a quick treat or ordering something special for a celebration. From classic flavors to seasonal creations, everything here feels thoughtfully crafted and perfect for sharing (or enjoying all to yourself!).

CoCo Bubble Tea

If your sweet tooth leans toward drinks instead of desserts, CoCo Bubble Tea is a must-visit. This popular bubble tea shop offers a wide range of milk teas, fruit teas, and slushes, all customizable with sweetness levels and toppings like boba, pudding, and jelly.

It’s a fun and refreshing stop while walking around Lexington Center, especially on warmer days. Whether you’re new to bubble tea or already a fan, CoCo has plenty of flavors to satisfy your cravings.

Tatte Bakery & Café

Tatte is a go-to spot for beautifully presented pastries, cookies, and desserts inspired by European and Middle Eastern flavors. Inside, you’ll find flaky croissants, seasonal tarts, brownies, cookies, or something sweet for brunch, perfect to pair with a coffee or latte.

Peet’s Coffee & Tea

Peet’s Coffee & Tea is a reliable stop for both caffeine and sweets. Alongside their coffee and tea offerings, you’ll find pastries such as muffins, scones, and cookies – simple, classic options when you’re in the mood for a small treat.

Located conveniently in Lexington Center, Peet’s makes an easy grab-and-go stop while sightseeing or shopping, especially if you want something sweet without committing to a full dessert stop.

When Pigs Fly Bread Company

When Pigs Fly is best known for its artisanal breads, but they serve up something sweet on weekends! Every Saturday and Sunday, Union Square Donuts pops up at the Lexington location so you can grab a donut (or a dozen) while picking up fresh-baked bread.

Wilson Farm

No list of sweet spots in Lexington would be complete without Wilson Farm. This beloved local institution offers an incredible bakery selection, including pies, cookies, cakes, donuts, and seasonal desserts that change throughout the year.

Whether you’re stopping by for apple cider donuts in the fall or picking up a slice of cake to enjoy later, Wilson Farm is a destination in itself. It’s perfect for families, food lovers, and anyone who wants to experience a true Lexington favorite.

Save room for dessert while in Lexington, MA, and take this post as your guide to the area’s sweeter side.